Mailchimp to Klaviyo Migration Guide: Step-by-Step

We've seen dozens of businesses hesitate at the crossroads between staying comfortable with Mailchimp and taking the leap to Klaviyo. It's understandable – migrating email platforms feels daunting, especially when you're managing customer relationships worth thousands in revenue. But here's what we've learnt after helping numerous e-commerce brands make this transition: the process is far more straightforward than most people imagine, and the benefits are immediate.

The truth is, businesses typically see significant improvements in engagement rates within the first month of switching. This isn't about chasing the latest trend – it's about giving your email marketing the advanced segmentation, automation capabilities, and e-commerce integration it deserves. You'll discover the exact seven-step process that ensures zero data loss, learn which elements require recreation versus direct transfer, and understand how to test everything thoroughly before going live.

Why Businesses Choose Klaviyo Over Mailchimp

Most of our clients come to us frustrated with Mailchimp's limitations around advanced segmentation and e-commerce integration. Klaviyo includes all automation features on its free plan, whilst Mailchimp restricts advanced automation to paid tiers. This fundamental difference becomes crucial when you're trying to create sophisticated customer journeys based on purchase behaviour.

The migration timeline varies depending on your account complexity, but plan for 2-4 weeks for a complete migration. This timeframe accounts for proper testing and validation – rushing this process is where businesses typically encounter problems. We always recommend starting your migration well before any major sales events or product launches.

Plan a 2–4 week window for your Mailchimp to Klaviyo migration to allow for setup, testing, and validation.

Understanding the platform differences upfront helps set realistic expectations. Mailchimp's free plan allows up to 500 contacts, whilst Klaviyo's free plan supports up to 250 contacts. However, what you gain in Klaviyo's advanced features often outweighs this contact limit difference for growing businesses.

Free plan limits: Mailchimp allows up to 500 contacts; Klaviyo supports up to 250, compensated by more advanced features.

Pre-Migration Planning and Documentation

Before touching any settings in either platform, spend time documenting your current setup. We cannot stress this enough – forms must be recreated in Klaviyo, so having detailed screenshots and notes about your existing forms, automations, and templates will save hours later.

Document every form, automation, and template before changing any settings to streamline the rebuild in Klaviyo.

Create a simple spreadsheet listing every signup form on your website, including pop-ups, embedded forms, and checkout opt-ins. Note which lists they feed into and any special tagging or segmentation rules. This documentation becomes your roadmap during the recreation phase. Many businesses skip this step and later discover they've missed critical touchpoints where customers join their email list.

Complex automations cannot be directly transferred, so document your current email sequences with their trigger conditions and timing. A simple flowchart for each automation helps you rebuild them accurately in Klaviyo. Pay particular attention to any conditional logic or branching in your sequences.

The Klaviyo migration planner tool can help you track all these elements systematically. Having everything documented in one place makes the actual migration process much smoother and reduces the likelihood of missing important components.

Setting Up Your Klaviyo Account

Start by creating your Klaviyo account and immediately connecting your e-commerce platform. Klaviyo provides a guided onboarding process, including connecting your website and setting up essential forms and flows. This integration is crucial because it enables Klaviyo's advanced e-commerce tracking from day one.

During the initial setup, resist the urge to start building everything immediately. Focus first on the technical integration – connecting Shopify, WooCommerce, or your chosen platform properly. This connection needs to be stable before you begin importing contacts or creating automations.

Verify that your website tracking is working correctly by placing a test order or completing a signup form. Check that these events appear in Klaviyo's activity feed. This validation step prevents issues later when you're wondering why your abandoned cart emails aren't triggering.

• Connect your e-commerce platform to Klaviyo
• Install Klaviyo's tracking code on your website
• Verify tracking with test actions (signup, purchase)
• Configure basic account settings and sender authentication

Exporting Data From Mailchimp

Export your contact lists from Mailchimp in CSV format, but don't just grab the basic list. Include all available fields – engagement data, tags, custom fields, and signup dates. Subscriber data and engagement metrics can be migrated, but historical open/click data may be limited. Understanding this limitation helps set proper expectations.

Download your campaign history and reports if you want to retain historical performance data for reference. Whilst this information won't integrate into Klaviyo's reporting, having it available helps you benchmark performance after the migration. Many businesses find it useful to create a simple comparison report showing pre and post-migration metrics.

Export each list separately rather than combining them into one large file. This approach makes the import process cleaner and helps maintain your existing segmentation structure. If you have different lists for different customer types or interests, preserve these distinctions during export.

For businesses with complex tagging systems, create a separate document mapping your Mailchimp tags to how you plan to structure them in Klaviyo. This planning step prevents confusion during the import process and ensures your segmentation strategy remains intact.

Importing Contacts Into Klaviyo

Import your contacts into Klaviyo using the platform's import tools, ensuring you map fields correctly to retain segmentation and tags. The field mapping stage is critical – take time to match your Mailchimp custom fields to appropriate Klaviyo properties.

Start with your most engaged segment first. Import your active subscribers before bringing over anyone who hasn't engaged recently. This approach helps establish good sending reputation with Klaviyo from the beginning. Klaviyo's integration tools help migrate subscriber data, including engagement metrics, but starting with your best contacts gives you the strongest foundation.

During the import process, create appropriate segments in Klaviyo that mirror your Mailchimp organisation. However, this is also an excellent opportunity to refine your segmentation strategy. Klaviyo's more advanced segmentation capabilities might allow you to create more precise audience definitions than you had in Mailchimp.

Recreating Forms and Automations

Now comes the manual recreation phase. Rebuild all sign-up forms (pop-ups, embedded forms, checkout opt-ins) in Klaviyo, using your documentation as a guide. This process takes longer than expected, so budget adequate time for testing each form thoroughly.

Start with your highest-converting forms first. If your exit-intent pop-up generates 40% of your email signups, recreate and test that one before moving to less critical forms. This prioritisation ensures your most important lead generation continues with minimal disruption.

Audit and test all forms to ensure they route new subscribers to Klaviyo without downtime or data loss. Test from multiple devices and browsers, and have team members complete test signups to verify everything works correctly. We've seen businesses lose potential customers because a form looked perfect on desktop but failed on mobile.

For automations, complex automations cannot be directly transferred, so rebuild each sequence in Klaviyo. This recreation process often reveals opportunities to improve your automation logic using Klaviyo's more advanced capabilities. You might discover you can create more sophisticated triggers or better personalisation than your original Mailchimp version.

Consider exploring behaviour-based segmentation in Klaviyo whilst recreating your automations. This platform excels at creating dynamic segments based on customer actions, which might enhance your existing automation strategy.

Testing and Validation Phase

Thoroughly test all forms, automations, and email templates in Klaviyo before pausing Mailchimp campaigns. Create a testing checklist that covers every customer touchpoint, from initial signup to post-purchase follow-up sequences.

Test all forms, flows, and templates thoroughly—across devices and browsers—before switching off Mailchimp.

Run both systems in parallel during the testing phase. Keep both systems running temporarily to ensure no gaps in customer communication and to validate that all data and flows function as intended. This parallel operation might seem redundant, but it's insurance against losing potential revenue during the transition.

Test each automation by triggering it manually with test email addresses. Complete actual purchases, abandon carts, and sign up for newsletters using different test accounts. Verify that the right emails send at the right times with the correct personalisation. Pay special attention to any conditional logic or product recommendations in your emails.

Document any discrepancies between your original Mailchimp setup and the recreated Klaviyo version. Some differences might be improvements (thanks to Klaviyo's advanced features), whilst others might need adjustment to match your original strategy.

1. Test all signup forms across devices and browsers
2. Trigger each automation sequence with test accounts
3. Verify email personalisation and dynamic content
4. Confirm tracking and analytics are recording correctly
5. Check that suppression lists are working properly

Going Live and Monitoring Performance

Once validation is complete, pause Mailchimp automations and switch all live campaigns to Klaviyo. Do this during a low-traffic period if possible, and have your team ready to respond quickly if any issues arise.

Monitor deliverability, engagement, and list growth in Klaviyo, using its analytics to optimise future campaigns. The first few sends are crucial for establishing your sender reputation with Klaviyo, so watch these metrics closely. Any significant drops in open rates or increases in spam complaints need immediate attention.

Expect some temporary fluctuations in performance during the first few weeks. Both platforms maintain strong deliverability when properly configured; sender reputation and list quality are more critical than platform choice. Focus on maintaining consistent sending patterns and engaging content rather than worrying about minor metric variations.

After the migration stabilises, explore Klaviyo's advanced features that weren't available in Mailchimp. Features like attribution window tools and AI-powered email marketing features can significantly enhance your results beyond what was possible with your previous platform.

Post-Migration Optimisation and Growth

With your migration complete, it's time to leverage the capabilities that made Klaviyo attractive in the first place. Use Klaviyo's analytics to review which forms, flows, and templates perform best, and continuously optimise based on data-driven insights. This ongoing optimisation often delivers more impact than the migration itself.

Explore advanced segmentation opportunities that Klaviyo enables. Create segments based on predicted customer lifetime value, purchase frequency, or browsing behaviour patterns. These sophisticated segments allow for more targeted messaging than most businesses could achieve with Mailchimp.

Consider implementing features like SMS marketing alongside your email campaigns, predictive analytics for inventory management, and advanced personalisation based on individual customer behaviour. Many businesses discover that Klaviyo's capabilities extend far beyond their original expectations.

For growing businesses, understanding advanced Klaviyo strategies becomes increasingly valuable as you scale. The platform grows with your business, offering enterprise-level features that support substantial revenue growth.

The journey from Mailchimp to Klaviyo represents more than a platform change – it's an upgrade to more sophisticated email marketing capabilities. Experts recommend allocating at least one month for a full migration, especially before major sales events, and this timeline proves worthwhile when you see the results.

Allocate at least one month for a complete migration—especially ahead of major sales periods.

Your immediate next step should be documenting your current Mailchimp setup if you haven't already started. Download our ESP migration management tool to track your progress systematically. Most businesses find that starting with documentation and planning makes the entire process smoother and more predictable.

Within 30 days, you'll likely notice improved engagement rates, better segmentation capabilities, and more sophisticated automation options. The investment in migration time pays dividends through enhanced customer relationships and increased revenue potential. Your email marketing deserves a platform that grows with your ambitions.

‍